Mary BerryRECIPES
Ingredient Substitutions

Caster Sugar vs Granulated Sugar: Does It Matter in Baking?

Caster sugar and granulated sugar are the same ingredient milled to different sizes — but that size changes how they dissolve, cream and measure. Here is when the difference matters, when it doesn't, and how to swap them gram for gram.

Caster Sugar vs Granulated Sugar: Does It Matter in Baking?
Share this guide:
💡

The Short Answer

Caster sugar and granulated sugar are the same white sugar milled to different crystal sizes — caster at 0.1–0.3 mm, granulated at 0.3–0.5 mm. Swap them gram for gram with no change, but use caster sugar for meringues, sponges and anything where the sugar must dissolve completely. By volume they differ: a cup of caster sugar weighs about 225 g against about 200 g for granulated, so always weigh the sugar when swapping.

The Short Answer: Same Sugar, Smaller Crystals

Yes — caster sugar vs granulated sugar matters, but only in some bakes. The two are the same ingredient: pure white sucrose, milled to different crystal sizes. Caster sugar is ground finer, so it dissolves faster and creams more smoothly into butter. Granulated sugar is the everyday table sugar with larger, more visible crystals.

For most everyday baking you can swap them, gram for gram, with no change at all. But in meringues, delicate sponges and anything where the sugar must dissolve completely, caster sugar is the right choice — and granulated sugar can leave a gritty texture or a speckled, weeping meringue.

The golden rule is simple: swap by weight, never by cup. A cup of caster sugar weighs slightly more than a cup of granulated sugar, because the finer crystals pack together more tightly. Weigh your sugar and the swap is exact.

What Is Caster Sugar, Exactly?

Caster sugar — also spelled castor sugar, and sold in the US as superfine sugar or baker's sugar — is ordinary refined white sugar that has been milled one step further than granulated sugar. The name comes from the caster, the small-holed shaker it was once sprinkled from over fruit and puddings at the table.

The difference is purely physical. Food scientist Harold McGee measured standard granulated sugar crystals at 0.3 to 0.5 mm across, and caster sugar crystals at 0.1 to 0.3 mm. That is the whole story: same sweetness, same chemistry, smaller grains. Caster sugar contains no added starch, which is what separates it from icing sugar — icing sugar is ground finer still (0.01 to 0.1 mm) and has a little cornflour added to stop it clumping.

Because the crystals are smaller, caster sugar has more surface area for its weight, so it dissolves faster in liquids and in batters, and it creams into soft butter more quickly and evenly. That is why nearly every Mary Berry sponge recipe calls for caster sugar rather than granulated: it disappears into the batter instead of sitting in it.

Caster sugar is sold in white and golden varieties. Golden caster sugar is unrefined, with a faint caramel note — lovely in ginger cakes and fruit cakes, but it will tint a pale sponge slightly. For a classic Victoria sponge, white caster sugar is the standard.

Caster Sugar vs Granulated Sugar at a Glance

At a glance, here is how the two sugars compare:

  • Crystal size: Granulated sugar 0.3–0.5 mm; caster sugar 0.1–0.3 mm.
  • Dissolving speed: Caster sugar dissolves noticeably faster, even in cool mixtures; granulated sugar needs heat or time.
  • Creaming with butter: Caster sugar creams in faster and traps air more evenly, giving a lighter sponge.
  • Weight per cup: About 200 g of granulated sugar per cup, against about 225 g of caster sugar per cup — the finer crystals pack more tightly. By weight they are identical: 100 g of either is 100 g of sugar.
  • Sweetness: Identical. Both are pure sucrose, so the sweetness per gram never changes.
  • Best for: Caster sugar — meringues, sponges, custards, mousses and whipped cream. Granulated sugar — biscuits, crumbles, jams, preserves and everyday sweetening.
  • Cost and availability: Granulated is cheaper and in every shop; caster sugar costs a little more but is stocked in every UK supermarket baking aisle.

One difference that catches people out is the cup measure. If a US recipe calls for a cup of superfine (caster) sugar and you measure a cup of granulated sugar instead, you are adding roughly 25 g less sugar than intended — enough to notice in a meringue. This is exactly why our cups to grams converter lists caster and granulated sugar separately: the same cup is not the same weight.

When Caster Sugar Really Matters

There are four bakes where caster sugar is not just better, it is genuinely the right ingredient:

  • Meringues. This is the big one. Sugar must dissolve fully into the egg white, or the meringue weeps, speckles and turns chewy. Granulated sugar's larger crystals often survive the whisking and leave gritty, sticky patches. Always use caster sugar for meringues — try it in our Perfect Meringue Nests and you will feel the difference in the first minute of whisking.
  • Sponge cakes. Caster sugar creams into butter faster and more evenly, trapping the fine air bubbles that give a Victoria sponge its lift. Granulated sugar can still work, but the crumb comes out slightly coarser. Our Classic Victoria Sponge Cake is built around caster sugar for exactly this reason.
  • Custards, mousses and possets. Anything where sugar must dissolve into a cool or barely warm liquid without graininess. Caster sugar melts in where granulated sugar can leave a sandy finish.
  • Whipped cream and buttercream. Caster sugar dissolves into cream without the crunch that granulated sugar leaves behind. If your buttercream has ever felt gritty, the sugar was the culprit — our guide to fixing grainy buttercream covers the rescue.

In short: if the sugar needs to vanish — into egg white, into butter, into cream — use caster sugar.

When Granulated Sugar Is Fine — or Better

Granulated sugar is not the poor relation — in several bakes it is the better choice, and in many more it makes no difference at all.

  • Biscuits and shortbread. A little crunch is a virtue here. Granulated sugar gives shortbread its characteristic sandy bite, and in cookies the larger crystals help the spread and the crisp edge. Our Classic Shortbread Biscuits are a case where granulated sugar is entirely at home.
  • Crumbles and streusel toppings. The larger crystals hold their shape and add crunch — caster sugar would simply melt into the topping.
  • Jams, marmalades and preserves. Sugar is dissolved in hot liquid for a long time, so crystal size is irrelevant. Granulated sugar is the economical, correct choice.
  • Tea, coffee and sprinkling over fruit. Granulated sugar is made for the table. Caster sugar works too, but there is no advantage in it.
  • Most traybakes, muffins and banana breads. In a robust, well-mixed batter with plenty of moisture and a longer bake, the two sugars behave identically once dissolved. Save the caster sugar for the bakes above.

If a recipe simply says "sugar" with no qualifier, it almost always means granulated sugar — and in the bakes listed here, that is exactly right.

How to Swap Them: The Weight Rule

Swapping caster sugar and granulated sugar is easy, as long as you follow two rules.

Rule 1: swap by weight, 1:1. 100 g of caster sugar is exactly the same amount of sugar as 100 g of granulated sugar — crystal size changes the volume, not the weight. If your recipe lists grams, just weigh out the same number.

Rule 2: if you measure by volume, adjust. A cup of caster sugar weighs about 225 g, while a cup of granulated sugar weighs about 200 g. So if a recipe calls for 1 cup of caster sugar and you only have granulated, use 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons of granulated sugar to match the weight. Going the other way, 1 cup of granulated sugar is roughly 1 cup of caster sugar minus 2 tablespoons. For small amounts — a tablespoon or two in a sauce or a dusting — the difference is too small to matter, and you can swap cup for cup without thinking.

The one swap to avoid is using granulated sugar in a meringue when the recipe calls for caster sugar. Even with careful whisking, some crystals may not dissolve, and the meringue can weep in the oven or turn sticky as it cools. If you have no caster sugar and a meringue is on the agenda, make some first — it takes thirty seconds, as the next section explains.

For sugar swaps beyond this pair — muscovado, golden syrup, demerara and the rest — our muscovado sugar substitutes guide ranks the options with exact ratios.

How to Make Caster Sugar from Granulated Sugar

If you run out of caster sugar mid-recipe, you do not need a trip to the shops. You can make it in about thirty seconds:

1. Pour the granulated sugar you need into a food processor fitted with the standard blade. 2. Pulse in short bursts for 20 to 30 seconds, stopping once or twice to scrape down the sides. 3. Stop as soon as the crystals look fine and powdery but still have a little grit when you rub them between your fingers.

Do not over-process it. Another thirty seconds and you will have something close to icing sugar, which behaves differently — it contains no cornflour, so it will clump, and its extra-fine texture can make a sponge dense rather than light. If you overshoot, it is still usable in a meringue, but start again for a sponge.

A blender works too, though a food processor gives a more even grind. Do not try this with a pestle and mortar — you will be there all afternoon, and the result will be uneven.

3 Mistakes to Avoid

Most failed caster-versus-granulated swaps fail in one of three ways, and all three are easy to avoid:

  • 1. Swapping cup for cup in a precise bake. A cup of caster sugar is about 25 g heavier than a cup of granulated sugar. In a sponge or a meringue that extra sugar changes the texture — too little and the bake is dry, too much and it browns too fast. Weigh the sugar and the problem disappears.
  • 2. Using granulated sugar in a meringue. This is the single most common cause of a gritty, weeping meringue. The crystals do not dissolve in the egg white, then melt in the oven and leak out as syrup. Use caster sugar, or grind your own first.
  • 3. Confusing caster sugar with icing sugar. They sit next to each other on the shelf and both look fine, but icing sugar is far finer and contains cornflour to stop it clumping. Icing sugar in a sponge makes a dense, heavy crumb, and in a meringue the cornflour can make it chalky. Keep them straight: caster sugar for baking, icing sugar for dusting and buttercream.

✨ Mary Berry's Caster Sugar Rule

"Caster sugar is the sugar I reach for in a sponge — it creams into the butter in moments and disappears into the batter, so the crumb comes out light and even. Granulated sugar has its place, but never in a meringue, where undissolved crystals will show."

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use granulated sugar instead of caster sugar in meringue?

You can, but the meringue may suffer for it. Granulated sugar's larger crystals often don't dissolve fully in the egg white, which leaves a gritty texture and can make the meringue weep syrup as it bakes. If you have no caster sugar, blitz granulated sugar in a food processor for 20 to 30 seconds first — that takes you most of the way there.

Is caster sugar the same as superfine sugar?

Yes — caster sugar and superfine sugar are the same product under different names. In the US it is usually labelled superfine sugar or baker's sugar, and in Canada it is sometimes sold as berry sugar. Substitute them 1:1 by weight.

Can I use caster sugar in tea or coffee?

Yes, both work fine in tea and coffee — granulated sugar is the usual choice, and caster sugar dissolves a little faster because its crystals are smaller. There is no flavour difference at all; it is purely a matter of which bag you reach for.

Charlotte Davies
Written by

Charlotte Davies

Lead Culinary Editor & British Baking Specialist

Passionate British baker and food writer specialising in traditional British home baking, foolproof kitchen science, and Mary Berry-inspired recipes.

Try These Classic Mary Berry Recipes

Put these tips to the test in the kitchen:

More Helpful Baking Guides